• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Matteo's Pizza: Authentic New York Slices & Fresh Pupusas in Kingston, NY

Matteo's Pizza in Kingston, NY, offers a unique blend of authentic New York-style pizza and freshly made pupusas, creating a rare and delightful culinary fusion. The owner’s warmth and generosity enhance the dining experience, with customers praising not only the flavorful, crispy pizza slices but also the vibrant pupusas served with curtido and salsa. Standout dishes like the rich Baked Ziti showcase homemade quality that rivals city standards. Matteo’s dedication to fresh ingredients and friendly service makes it a standout spot for comforting, hearty meals that keep patrons returning. A must-visit for lovers of genuine, thoughtfully crafted Italian and Central American flavors.

Matteo's Pizza at a glance

  • Address 652 Broadway, Kingston, NY 12401, United States
  • Phone +1 845-338-8300
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant , Meal delivery .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Matteo's Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Julian Guevara
5

Honestly one of the best spots to get a slice! Dont let me forget the Pupusas! They are made fresh and were just as good if not better than the Pupusas I get back home in Los Angeles, Ca. Where else in the world can you get an authentic New York slice and an authentic pupusa in the same restaurant? If you’re in the area definitely check them out! The owner and staff were really friendly! The next time I’m in this area I’m coming back for a slice and pupusa

Goddess
5

My man and I went out to dinner in kingston late one sunday, and nothing was open. Matteo's was closing down, the pizzas where all put away, and we walked in hungry. We asked the man behind the counter if he would serve us, or if we missed our chance? The man behind the counter ( who i assume was Matteo) smiled, and proceeded to take out the pizzas he had put away for the night, and asked us what we wanted out of the selection he had. Being hungry and grateful, we ordered several slices (to go) with a few drinks. Meanwhile Matteo had turned his oven back on, heated our slices and even threw one in for free! He was so kind and generous and we where so thankful! 10/10 service and the pizza, turns out, was FANTASTIC! We will be returning at a reasonable hour for more pizza soon! Thank You Matteo <3

Larry Legend
5

I love Matteo's! The pizza is great. If want something really tasty, stop by in person and get a couple of fresh-made pupusas. They come with curtido (cabbage salad) and tasty salsa and you won't find a better deal on a meal anywhere.

Jon Towers
5

I ordered takeout and got one of the best Baked Ziti w/ meatsauce that I've had from a public joint! As close to authentic homemade as I've seen outside of the City!

Marcello Gros
5

The owner/worker was very kind and helpful. Also have many specialty pizzas that all sound good

Gabrielle P
5

I’ve been having a hard time finding wings I like, they’re usually small, greasy and not worth the price. These are worth the price, large chicken wings. I hope they never switch vendors.

Amani Stevenson
5

Very good, got a buffalo chicken slice, mozzarella sticks and eggplant slice.. it was so amazing.. I don’t usually like places blue cheese but I’d come back just for the dressing lol definitely will be back. It’s a place I tumbled across but have now added to my favorites ..

Dalton Jones
5

Well, this is a quiet little gem. I was actually on my way down the street to eat at another more loudly advertised pizza joint but stopped in here on a whim. First of all, the pizza was really good. I mean, that’s what really matters. But second of all, it’s got that local neighborhood feel. They keep their relationship with the community honest and down to earth. That’s the kind of place I like to spend my money. Of the people, by the people, for the people.

Location

  • Matteo's Pizza
    Matteo's Pizza
    652 Broadway, Kingston, NY 12401, United States Hotline: +1 845-338-8300

Matteo’s Pizza, nestled at 652 Broadway in Kingston, NY, stands out as a gem for anyone craving authentic New York-style pizza with a unique twist. This place doesn’t just serve slices; it offers an experience enriched by warm hospitality and unexpected culinary delights. What captures attention first is their blend of classic Italian flavors with Central American staples, most notably their fresh-made pupusas served alongside the traditional New York slice. This rare fusion brings a vibrant diversity to the menu, setting Matteo’s apart in a crowded pizza scene.

Customers consistently praise the friendly, generous nature of the owner, Matteo himself, who goes above and beyond to make every visit memorable. Whether it’s turning the oven back on after closing time to reheat slices or generously sharing a free piece, the service here is as comforting as the food. This personal touch makes the dining experience feel truly genuine and inviting.

Beyond pizza, the pupusas come highly recommended, arriving fresh and paired with curtido cabbage salad and flavorful salsa. These perfectly complement the robust flavors of a classic New York slice, offering an exciting contrast of textures and tastes that reflect Matteo’s culinary creativity. The baked ziti with meat sauce is another highlight, delivering hearty, homemade authenticity that rivals the best you’d find in New York City itself.

Matteo’s Pizza captures the essence of comfort food with quality and care, blending authentic recipes with an inclusive atmosphere. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick slice or ordering takeout of their specialty dishes, expect warmth in both food and service. For pizza enthusiasts and food adventurers alike, this spot is a must-visit in Kingston’s vibrant food landscape.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Outdoor seating
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards